Games likeSupernatural

Tap a tag once for more of it, twice for none of it.

Start from another game
AA

Shadow Warrior 3: Definitive Edition

25% matchDemons, FPS

69%4.8K reviews
AA

Dead Estate

24% matchDemons, Horror

94%5.8K reviewsDeck
AAA

Inscryption

24% matchPsychological, Horror

96%135.9K reviews10 h
AA

SCP: Nine-Tailed Fox

28% matchSurvival Horror, Horror

76%3.8K reviews
AAA

Mafia: Definitive Edition

27% matchCrime, Story Rich

86%89.8K reviews
AA

Crime Scene Cleaner: Prologue

28% matchCrime, Detective

94%5.4K reviews
Obscure

Don't Die, Minerva!

25% matchAdventure, Action, Similar premise

68%32 reviews
Obscure

MÅRD

34% matchHorror, Adventure, Similar premise

12%16 reviews
Indie

Lucius

26% matchHorror, Stealth

80%7.8K reviews3 h
Obscure

Blackout: The Darkest Night

29% matchPsychological Horror, Horror, Similar premise

81%22 reviews
Indie

CloverPit

25% matchPsychological, Psychological Horror

90%25.3K reviewsDeck
Obscure

Ghost Case

30% matchHorror, Adventure, Similar premise

58%17 reviews
Obscure

困兽TrappedBeast

30% matchHorror, Puzzle, Similar premise

75%62 reviews
AAA

The Callisto Protocol™

28% matchSurvival Horror, Horror, survival horror

66%35.2K reviews9.5 hDeck
Indie

Into the Radius VR

28% matchFPS, Horror

93%9.7K reviews
Indie

The Mortuary Assistant

31% matchDemons, Horror

92%7.3K reviews5 hDeck
Indie

The Roottrees are Dead

30% matchDetective, Investigation

96%10K reviews7.5 h
AAA

Far Cry®

29% matchFPS, Stealth

81%11.2K reviews12 h
AAA

Friday the 13th: The Game

35% matchSurvival Horror, Horror

80%76.8K reviews
Obscure

Paranormal Detective: Escape from the 90's

29% matchDetective, Puzzle

79%53 reviews
AA

Strange Antiquities

28% matchDetective, Investigation

95%3.4K reviewsDeck
Indie

BONELAB

24% matchPsychological, FPS

82%19K reviews
AA

THE 4 SINS

25% matchDetective, Horror

23%3.4K reviews
AA

System Shock

27% matchSurvival Horror, Horror, survival horror

90%9.9K reviews
Indie

Cyber Manhunt

25% matchCrime, Detective

92%14.5K reviews
AA

Halls of Torment

22% matchDemons, Dark

95%30.9K reviewsDeck
Indie

Investigator

32% matchHorror, Adventure, Similar premise

69%1.1K reviews2 h
Obscure

Haunted Record

31% matchInvestigation, Adventure, Similar premise

97%41 reviews
AA

In Silence

36% matchHorror, Survival Horror

75%9.5K reviews
Obscure

The Overseer

32% matchInvestigation, Horror, Similar premise

100%14 reviews
Obscure

Haunted Hotel: Eternity Collector's Edition

34% matchDetective, Investigation

90%10 reviews
Indie

Gunpoint

24% matchStealth, Puzzle

97%10.3K reviews4 h
AAA

Alice: Madness Returns

22% matchPsychological, Horror

90%28.2K reviews13 h
Indie

Perfect Heist 2

23% matchDetective, Stealth

94%3.7K reviews2 h
Indie

PUMPKIN PANIC

24% matchHorror, Survival Horror

96%4.2K reviews
Indie

Slender: The Arrival

35% matchHorror, Survival Horror

88%7.9K reviews
AA

Crisol: Theater of Idols

31% matchSurvival Horror, FPS

85%4.2K reviewsDeck
Indie

Orion Sandbox Enhanced

25% matchOften compared to it, Adventure, Action

94%1.2K reviews
Indie

DREDGE

26% matchPsychological Horror, Psychological

95%48.3K reviewsDeck
AA

Yuppie Psycho: Executive Edition

27% matchStealth, Survival Horror

95%8.1K reviews6 hDeck
AA

FOREWARNED

33% matchSurvival Horror, Horror

90%5K reviews
Indie

Home

31% matchHorror, Psychological

69%1.1K reviews1.7 hDeck
Obscure

Ghost Master: Resurrection

28% matchHorror, Puzzle, Similar premise

82%393 reviews
AA

INDIKA

28% matchPsychological, Horror

89%7.2K reviews3.7 hDeck
Obscure

Nightmare Visions Chapter 1

29% matchHorror, First-Person, Similar premise

57%49 reviews
AA

Nuclear Nightmare

34% matchSurvival Horror, Horror

81%15.6K reviews
Indie

Mad Father

30% matchPsychological Horror, Horror

97%6.3K reviewsDeck
AA

REANIMAL

27% matchHorror, Dark

78%14.1K reviews5.5 hDeck