ObscureSpooky Men
25% matchHorror, First-Person
AAABorderlands 4
24% matchOnline Co-Op, Co-op
AAAbiotic Factor
24% matchCo-op Campaign, Online Co-Op
IndieSerious Sam 4
25% matchOften compared to it, Co-op, First-Person
AAHello Neighbor
25% matchHorror, Psychological Horror
AACodename CURE
25% matchOnline Co-Op, Co-op
ObscureIt's Six Random Characters and a Single Floor Dungeon, That's the Whole Game
26% matchRoguelite, Procedural Generation, Similar premise
AAPlateUp!
23% matchCo-op, Online Co-Op
IndieThe Room Three
25% matchPuzzle, Lovecraftian
AAStrinova
21% matchTeam-Based, Online Co-Op, team-based
ObscureDepths of Madness
33% matchHorror
AAProject Winter
23% matchTeam-Based, PvE
AAAThe Evil Within
28% matchHorror, Psychological Horror
AAFive Nights at Freddy's: Secret of the Mimic
25% matchHorror, First-Person
ObscureCountless Rooms of Death
29% matchHorror, Similar premise
AAMISERY
28% matchOnline Co-Op, Co-op
IndieIndigo Park: Chapter 1
30% matchHorror, First-Person
IndieSpiral Knights
25% matchOnline Co-Op, Co-op
IndieKinitoPET
22% matchPsychological Horror, Horror
IndieSCP: Secret Laboratory
31% matchHorror, Co-op
ObscureLong Time No See
25% matchHorror, Supernatural
AAAHELLDIVERS™ Dive Harder Edition
22% matchOnline Co-Op, Co-op
AAASons Of The Forest
28% matchCo-op, Horror
AAARec Room
24% matchOnline Co-Op, Co-op
AAAPEAK
31% matchOnline Co-Op, Co-op
AAACONTROL Ultimate Edition
22% matchSupernatural, Horror
AADead Island 2
26% matchCo-op, Horror, gore
AAOutward Definitive Edition
24% matchOnline Co-Op, Co-op
IndieUndertale
21% matchPsychological Horror, Horror
IndieUnrailed!
22% matchOnline Co-Op, Co-op
IndieLISA: The Painful
21% matchPsychological Horror, Horror
ObscureSwarm Horror
27% matchHorror, First-Person
AAUnboxing the Cryptic Killer
29% matchOnline Co-Op, Co-op
AASIGNALIS
23% matchLovecraftian, Psychological Horror
AADungeon Defenders
27% matchOnline Co-Op, Team-Based
IndieBaldi's Basics Plus
25% matchProcedural Generation, Horror
AAANo Rest for the Wicked
21% matchOnline Co-Op, Character Customization
AAHalloween: The Game
28% matchHorror, Online Co-Op
AAWitchfire
21% matchHorror, Character Customization
ObscureReal Scary
28% matchHorror, Psychological Horror
AAStill Wakes the Deep
28% matchLovecraftian, Horror, gore
ObscureRoyal Revolt Survivors
27% matchCo-op, Roguelite
IndieINSIDE
21% matchHorror, Action-Adventure
AAAInscryption
22% matchHorror, Roguelite
IndieBLOCKADE
24% matchCo-op, Team-Based
AAAlan Wake
27% matchHorror, Psychological Horror, lovecraftian
AAABioShock™
21% matchHorror, Atmospheric, gore
AASuperliminal
23% matchPsychological Horror, Puzzle