Games likeSupernatural

Tap a tag once for more of it, twice for none of it.

Start from another game
Indie

The Cabin Factory

35% matchPsychological Horror, Horror

90%3.5K reviewsDeck
AA

BIGFOOT

34% matchSurvival Horror, Horror

83%17.9K reviews
Indie

Fran Bow

34% matchPsychological Horror, Psychological

97%20.7K reviews7 hDeck
Indie

Thief Simulator

28% matchCrime, Stealth

88%37.6K reviews4 h
Obscure

Boogeyman 3

36% matchHorror, Psychological Horror, Similar premise

70%20 reviews
Obscure

Expel

33% matchHorror, Action, Similar premise

66%12 reviews
Obscure

Immortal Mantis

30% matchPsychological Horror, Horror, Similar premise

94%226 reviews
AA

Paradise Killer

33% matchCrime, Detective

93%3.3K reviews1 hDeck
Obscure

SEARCH PARTY: Director's Cut

33% matchHorror, Action-Adventure, Similar premise

92%113 reviews
Obscure

Halloween Chronicles: Behind the Door Collector's Edition

32% matchPsychological Horror, Horror, Similar premise

86%15 reviews
Obscure

Lighthouse of Madness

37% matchPsychological Horror, Horror, Similar premise

95%22 reviews
Indie

Indigo Park: Chapter 1

37% matchHorror, Survival Horror

95%23.5K reviews1 h
Obscure

DEEP IN THE DREAD

34% matchFPS, Action-Adventure, Similar premise

45%11 reviews
Obscure

Mystery Manor: hidden objects

32% matchDetective, Investigation, Similar premise

41%89 reviews
AA

Missing Hiker

34% matchPsychological Horror, Horror

84%3.8K reviews1 h
AAA

METRO Last Light Redux

30% matchStealth, FPS

91%72.1K reviews8.7 hDeck
AA

Murky Divers

30% matchSurvival Horror, Psychological Horror

87%4K reviewsDeck
AAA

Dead by Daylight

37% matchHorror, Survival Horror, survival horror

78%692.8K reviews77 hDeck
Obscure

28 Leicester Square

32% matchHorror, Investigation, Similar premise

82%17 reviews
Obscure

The elevator

32% matchHorror, Adventure, Similar premise

86%104 reviews
Indie

IMSCARED

35% matchPsychological Horror, Horror

95%3.5K reviews1 h
AA

The Test: Hypothesis Rising

33% matchDetective, Psychological

97%5.8K reviewsDeck
Obscure

What You Don't See

34% matchInvestigation, Horror, supernatural

76%13 reviews
Obscure

A Call From Under the House

33% matchDetective, Investigation, Similar premise

90%10 reviews
Obscure

Secrets of Salem: Shadow of the Witch Collector's Edition

39% matchDetective, Investigation, Similar premise

84%13 reviews
AA

Dark Hours: Prologue

39% matchHorror, Survival Horror

88%6.3K reviews
AA

Darkwood

33% matchSurvival Horror, Psychological Horror

94%22.5K reviews14 hDeck
Obscure

The Witch

35% matchHorror, First-Person, Similar premise

60%20 reviews
Obscure

Kach

36% matchHorror, Dark

82%296 reviews1 h
AA

Saihate Station

29% matchPsychological Horror, Crime

95%10.7K reviews
Obscure

Revengeful Ghost

34% matchPsychological Horror, Horror, Similar premise

71%56 reviews
Indie

Pony Island

28% matchDemons, Psychological Horror

95%14.9K reviews2.5 hDeck
Obscure

Creepy Camping

34% matchHorror, Psychological Horror, Similar premise

79%24 reviews
Obscure

Underground: Chapter 1

33% matchHorror, Action-Adventure, Similar premise

66%12 reviews
Obscure

The Eerie Surroundings

34% matchPsychological Horror, Horror, Similar premise

81%11 reviews
AA

Hello Neighbor 2

32% matchStealth, Survival Horror

81%4.5K reviews
Obscure

Lost Alone

33% matchAction, Horror, Similar premise

84%13 reviews
AAA

Dishonored

29% matchStealth, First-Person

97%67.9K reviews9 hDeck
Obscure

SNAP SNAP

40% matchPsychological Horror, Demons

81%79 reviews
Obscure

The Night Is Long

35% matchPsychological Horror, Psychological

83%49 reviews
AAA

A Plague Tale: Innocence

30% matchStealth, Story Rich

93%64.3K reviews8.5 h
Indie

Secret Neighbor: Hello Neighbor Multiplayer

33% matchStealth, Survival Horror

86%14.9K reviews
Indie

Dark Deception

34% matchHorror, Survival Horror

88%24.4K reviews
AAA

Indiana Jones and the Great Circle

29% matchStealth, Investigation

89%13.2K reviews17 hDeck
Obscure

24H Stories: The Blackout

32% matchPsychological, Horror

92%26 reviews
Obscure

Westmark Manor

33% matchSurvival Horror, Adventure, Similar premise

68%47 reviews
Obscure

Root Of Evil: The Tailor

36% matchHorror, Puzzle, Similar premise

83%470 reviews
Obscure

The Backrooms: Expedition

37% matchPsychological Horror, Horror

66%18 reviews